Dec. 23, 2020 — The headlines are sobering: “COVID-19 Deaths Surpass 9/11 Deaths in Single Day,” and, extra not too long ago, “2020 is the Deadliest Yr in U.S. Historical past.”

It appears that evidently having 3,000 folks die every day ought to spark widespread compassion and a change in public conduct to cease the unfold of the virus. However not so. Regardless of pleas to remain put, vacation vacationers at Thanksgiving crammed airports in report numbers for the pandemic, and airports are reporting busy journey for Christmas as properly. Folks simply don’t ignore stay-at-home orders, they flout them. In Los Angeles, police arrested 158 folks at a ”super-spreader” celebration, regardless of stay-at-home orders. And loads of folks nonetheless argue they’ve a proper to not put on a masks.

This seeming indifference that units in after we’re confronted with such a disaster is understood by mental health consultants as psychic numbing, says Paul Slovic, PhD, a professor of psychology on the College of Oregon, Eugene, and president of Choice Analysis, a nonprofit institute that investigates selections of recent life.

Psychic numbing ”is a scarcity of feeling related to info,” he says. “The which means of knowledge is closely decided by the sensation that info creates in us.”

“If some info conveys a constructive feeling, that’s a sign to method regardless of the state of affairs is. If it sends a detrimental feeling, it’s a sign to retreat. We’d like these emotions to really perceive the which means of the data.”

How we react to a disaster just like the pandemic depends upon the mode of considering we’re utilizing, Slovic says. He cites the work of psychologist Daniel Kahneman, winner of a Nobel Prize in economics for his work on decision-making and creator of the bestseller Considering Quick and Gradual.

Gradual considering makes use of mathematical fashions, Slovic says; it is how we have been taught to suppose in class. “We will suppose that manner however hardly ever do it as a result of it is arduous work,” he says. “The human mind is lazy; if it will possibly [process information] by way of feeling, that is our default mode of considering.”

The one option to perceive the impression of the COVID toll, Slovic says, is to suppose slowly and thoroughly so we perceive what science is telling us. With out doing so, because the numbers get greater and greater, he says, ”you do not really feel something in any respect; it is only a quantity.”

As Tragedy Rises, Concern Does not Preserve Up

Of their analysis, Slovic and others even have discovered that somebody’s concern about others at risk does not improve with the variety of folks affected. “One particular person at risk can sign a whole lot of robust emotions,” he says. “Folks will threat their lives to avoid wasting somebody at risk.” That is very true if the particular person is a liked one, he says.

Nonetheless, ”if I informed you there have been two folks at risk, you wouldn’t really feel twice as involved. You might be already feeling concern about one. If there have been two, you may really feel somewhat extra involved.” Or, you may really feel much less involved as a result of your consideration is split.

In a single study, Slovic and his workforce offered three scenarios to varsity college students: a 7-year-old lady who was desperately poor and wanted assist, a 9-year-old boy who was desperately poor and wanted assist, or each needing assist. College students gave greater donations when one particular person wanted assist, he discovered.

He concluded that the decline in compassion could start with the second endangered life.

Relating to the COVID loss of life and case totals, he says, ”you do not have a way of the person lives. That is psychic numbing. You lose feeling, you lose feelings. These are [just] dry statistics.”

Psychic Numbing and Different Points

Psychic numbing can be frequent in different points, together with local weather change, says Leif Griffin, PsyD, a medical psychologist within the San Francisco Bay Space

“Psychic numbing is that this adaptive manner of not feeling or totally registering on an emotional degree the type of menace or, in some methods, the traumatic expertise that’s occurring,” he says.

So, yearly turns into hotter, however ”we do not wish to take into consideration what it means to our planet,” Griffin says. Psychic numbing permits us to ”pay attention to one thing however not emotionally course of or be in contact with the factor that’s occurring.”

In a manner, Griffin says, psychic numbing is like saying, ”Do not intrude on my sense of security.”

Robert Jay Lifton, MD, a distinguished professor emeritus of psychiatry and psychology at The Metropolis College of New York, coined the time period psychic numbing.

“After I interviewed survivors of the primary atomic bomb dropped on a human inhabitants in Hiroshima, they typically described their minds type of shutting down. I got here to name that psychic numbing.”

And, he says, “it may be adaptive,” serving to folks cope in some conditions. Of their instances, he says, it was a protection mechanism to get by way of the expertise.

However when psychic numbing persists within the face of hazard, Lifton says, it will possibly create appreciable issues, resulting in withdrawal and even depression. It is one of many signs of posttraumatic stress disorder (PTSD), he says.

Psychic numbing is enjoying a task within the COVID pandemic, Lifton says, as folks use it to attempt to maintain off their anxiety about loss of life.

Decreasing COVID’s ‘Psychic Numbing’

Psychic numbing can have an effect on conduct, together with resistance to mask-wearing and different preventive measures, Slovic and Lifton agree.

Public well being consultants want statistics to battle COVID, Slovic says, however he suggests additionally they attempt to set off a sense after they current numbers in the event that they wish to scale back psychic numbing.

For example, displaying a graph that reveals the upward tendencies of instances and deaths might assist. “Even when you do not know the precise quantity, you possibly can see the curve goes straight up. You get a sense from taking a look at that fast-increasing curve,” he says.

Speaking about particular person instances is one other good option to lower psychic numbing, Slovic says. And as statistics are offered, well being care suppliers ought to speak about crowded intensive care items and emergency rooms, he says. Tales of people that contracted COVID after denying the danger are additionally highly effective, he says.

WebMD Well being Information


Paul Slovic, PhD, professor of psychology, College of Oregon; president, Choice Analysis, Eugene, OR.

Leif Griffin, PsyD, medical psychologist, San Francisco Bay Space.

Robert Jay Lifton, MD, distinguished professor emeritus of psychiatry and psychology, The Metropolis College of New York.

American Psychological Affiliation: “Paul Slovic observes the ‘psychic numbing’ of COVID-19.” 

WebMD: “CVID-19 Deaths Surpass 911 Deaths in Single Day.”

The Hill: “CDC Director: US COVID-19 Deaths More likely to Exceed 911 Toll for 60 Days.”

PLoS One: “Compassion Fade: Have an effect on and Charity Are Biggest for a Single Little one in Want.”

© 2020 WebMD, LLC. All rights reserved.